How Perfectionism Keeps Us Stuck: Learning to Live in the Grey
For a long time, I didn’t think of myself as someone who struggled with perfectionism. If anything, I saw myself as intentional, thoughtful, and deeply invested in growth. But when I look back more honestly, I can see that much of my life was lived in a kind of chronic “wait mode.”
Waiting for things to feel right.
Waiting until I had full clarity.
Waiting until I had the perfect plan before I began.
It showed up in simple, everyday ways, like not starting something until I had fully figured out how it should go, or delaying action until I felt mentally prepared enough to execute it well. Even when I was putting in effort, it often came in the form of thinking, researching, and planning.
And I told myself a story that made this pattern feel justified.
I believed that I was giving things my 100%. That I was learning, preparing, and setting myself up to do things well. That by thinking things through deeply, I was avoiding mistakes and being efficient with my time and energy.
But over time, something started to feel off.
Because despite all the effort, things weren’t really moving in the way I expected. There was a kind of quiet exhaustion that came with it, this feeling of always needing to know more, figure out more, prepare more before anything could actually happen. It felt like I was doing a lot, but still somehow holding myself back.
What I couldn’t see at the time was that this wasn’t just about being thorough or thoughtful. It was a pattern. And more importantly, it was a protective one.
That became clearer to me during a peer coaching session that shifted something quite unexpectedly.
As I was talking about a project I had been wanting to start, I noticed how naturally I moved into explaining all the ways I was thinking about it, how it should be structured, how I wanted it to feel, how I could get it right. And then my coach reflected something simple back to me: “I sense a lot of pressure to do it the right way.”
It landed immediately.
Because I could see it so clearly in that moment. The pressure wasn’t just in that one project, it was everywhere. In how I approached decisions, relationships, work, even personal growth. There was always an underlying need to do things correctly, to get it right, to not waste effort.
And the reason it was so hard to question this pattern is because, in many ways, it worked.
When you plan carefully, think things through, and execute with precision, you often do get results. Things turn out well. You avoid certain mistakes. From the outside, it looks effective.
And that’s exactly how the pattern sustains itself.
Because when something works, we rarely question it.
We start to believe that this is the right way to function. That more planning will lead to better outcomes. That more control will create more success. And so we double down; we think more, plan more, refine more.
But what often goes unnoticed is the cost.
The time spent in preparation instead of participation; The energy spent in overthinking instead of experiencing; The subtle but constant tension of needing to get things right.
What we tell ourselves is that we are saving time and resources. But in reality, we are often spending a significant amount of both in our heads, before we even begin.
From a trauma-informed perspective, this pattern makes a lot of sense.
The need to do things “right,” to plan ahead, and to seek clarity before action can be understood as a way the nervous system tries to create safety. When uncertainty feels uncomfortable, the mind steps in to organize, predict, and control. It reduces risk. It creates a sense of stability.
In that way, perfectionism and overthinking are not flaws, they are strategies.
They protect us from failure, from judgment, from the discomfort of not knowing. They give us a sense of control in situations that might otherwise feel unpredictable.
But protection can become limitation when it starts to restrict how we live.
This became even more clear when another idea came up in that session: what would it mean to be comfortable living in the grey?
I noticed an immediate resistance to that. There is a part of me that prefers clarity, direction, and certainty. I want to know if something is working, if it’s meaningful, if it’s leading somewhere.
But living in the grey asks something very different.
It asks us to take action without guaranteed outcomes. To step into situations without fully knowing how they will unfold. To allow experiences to be incomplete, undefined, or even disappointing, without making that mean something about us.
It shifts the focus from getting it right to simply showing up.
And that’s not something that can be understood purely at an intellectual level.
One of the patterns I’ve had to confront is the tendency to rely on understanding before experience. The belief that if I can just learn enough, research enough, or think something through deeply enough, then I’ll be able to do it with ease.
But many of the shifts we are trying to make don’t happen through thinking. They happen through doing, through allowing ourselves to be in the very experiences we’ve been trying to prepare for.
This is where real capacity is built.
Not by eliminating discomfort or waiting for certainty, but by gradually increasing our ability to stay present in situations that feel uncertain, imperfect, or unresolved.
When I look at it this way, the overwhelm that often accompanies these patterns starts to make more sense. It’s not just about having too much to do, but about the pressure attached to everything we do. The sense that there is a right way, and that we need to find it before we begin.
That pressure can make even simple actions feel heavy.
So the shift is not necessarily about doing more, or even doing things better. It’s about relating to our actions differently. Allowing space for imperfection. Letting things be a little messy. Taking steps without needing full clarity.
This is not about abandoning structure or intention, but about loosening the grip of control just enough to let life move.
Because at some point, the question is no longer whether something is the right way to do it.
It’s whether we are willing to step into it at all.
And for many of us, that’s where the real work begins.
Check out my other posts:
